viernes, marzo 31, 2006

Science and religion are NOT compatible.

There has always been a lot of fuzz about wheather science and religion are compatible. My short answer is NO. We may need to either widen or narrow the implications of "compatible" to clarify or further the discussion, but on general grounds I make an affirmation that science and religion ARE NOT compatible.

It's common to hear that both religion and science are tools to search for truth, or tools in the search of truth, but I find this really hard to buy. First of all, because on science truth is a tricky concept, there is no truth in science, but validity. You may argue about the truth of a statement, based on the evidence presented, but the validity of an argument (a scientific theory) is a different thing.

The realm of religion has always been in the ignorance of mankind. Religion tells us to believe blindly in incredible premises but doesn't allows to question its methods. Science on the other hand, shows us incredibles premises, tells us its methods, and the encourage us to question its explanations; each passing day the realm of religion is becoming more and more constrict.

Religion insists to hold the truth, but there is no validity on its arguments. There are many good ideas in religion, but at the same time there are utterly horrible sentences. How could you possibly seek validity or truth from such premises?

For religion to be compatible with science, religion must learn to adapt itself to new knowledge, to demand proof of statements, to challenge its own ideas for endurance... but then again, it wouldn't be religion.

1 comentario:

papaesceptico dijo...

Saludos! interesantes entradas! a cerca si de la religión compatible con la ciencia??? estoy de acuerdo, no lo son, y hay infinidad de gente que dice que si, sin embargo, la religión ha tenido que esconderse tras la ciencia, y actualizar sus cuentos mágicos! pero también pregunto, que ciencia? biología física... la evolución no lo es... la medicina si lo es, pero entra la duda.. porque dios nos trae enfermedades? el religioso te dice que fue un milagro de dios si se salva, y si se muere, dios lo mando llamar, pero el religiosos si acepta la medicina sin cuestionarse el porque estos males estan aquí... o si dios es bueno o malo por habernos dado esto! (pecado original nuestra culpa) esto nunca acabaria... etc etc...

la religión no tiene respuestas a sus preguntas... por lo que tiene que reinventar sus historias, por lo que la religión también EVOLUCIONA! :)

la religión no puede cuestionarse sus creencias, sino, la religión ya no existiría! por eso la palabra Escéptico y Religión no se llevan!